Repetition

IMG_6982

Me at my favorite fort in India, the Red Fort

To get to the Lufthansa lost and found desk during a layover in the Frankfurt airport, you need to

  • have a true friend or two to help you withstand the scary emotional implications of a lost iPhone
  • go through customs and earn two German passport stamps
  • marvel at the Volkswagen taxis everywhere
  • ring three separate yet intercom-connected doorbells
  • speed walk on a moving walkway

In what has now congealed itself as a Bressler family tradition, I lost my phone in Germany. I do not know how, but somewhere between the fog of the airplane and security, it went missing. My first lost phone ever. What could have been a devastating experience turned into one that was a reminder of how profoundly lucky I am to be with people that look out for my well-being.

Before I left India, I wondered what I would come home with and what I would leave behind.

Concretely, my bags weigh more because of scarves and extra dirt and the two Tagore books that Ammu bought me. I left behind a pair of headphones, an empty bottle of conditioner, 12 Cliff Bars wrappers, the third photos of the Taj Mahal.

Goodbyes are weird. They never feel complete. You can say goodbye once, draw someone in for a hug and cry a little but there is always so much left unsaid. During our final bus ride as a group, Elisa and Matt read superlatives. Rose got “Most Likely to Use Professor Ganguly’s Dating Service.” Kate’s was “Most Likely to Write the Screenplay for Mother Theresa Superstar.” My favorite was Gavin’s because it was so simple. “Thirstiest.” He once drank a five-liter bottle of water in less than 24 hours.

IMG_6940

Stylin’ shoe covers

This is another way to say I am really going to miss these people. I am really going to miss India.

 

Currently, the book in my lap is “Poor Economics,” which is written by the founders of my future co-op, J-PAL. J-PAL’s work is, succinctly, about utilizing research-based solutions to end poverty. In the book, there are countless examples around places I have been to: Udaipur, Kolkata and Mumbai. Three times in India and I am beginning to understand things more. The cities are no longer just scribbles on a page but they are also people I met, places I journaled about.

Trying to summarize five weeks in India feels impossible in the way that it feels impossible to summarize just one day. On one of my last nights in Delhi, I stared at the traffic and looked out at hundreds of cars at a standstill. Repeat and repeat. The reiterations are everywhere: carts with dozens of mangos, hundreds of faces awe-stricken by their first sight of the Taj Mahal, dusty roads with enormous slabs of marble one after the other, hexagonal curves looping around and around in the windowpanes in Rajasthan’s palaces. It makes me feel so small. In another sense, I feel overwhelmed by the sheer amount of things to see and care about: sanitation, climate change, poverty, inequality, healthcare, child beggars, Bollywood movies, Modi and disappearing red crabs.

On one of the winding drives in Shillong, Professor Ganguly yelled at me to look out the window when we passed by a particularly beautiful waterfall or a goat sneezing by the side of the road. “Are you awake? Are your eyes open?” Afterwards, everyone in my car laughed about this moment. I was the only person in the car who stayed awake the whole time.

IMG_7054

A glimpse of my first tiger in the wild

 

In this post-India phase, I want more than anything, to keep my eyes open, to take in both inspiring and painful sights and to never stop caring about what I see. I want to be able to shout “Yes I am awake. My eyes are open.” Full stop.

 

Advertisements
Posted in 2016 | Tagged , , , , , , , , | 2 Comments

Long Hugs and New Friends

In India, I hear more. When you strip away the constant noise of needless newsfeeds and buzzing text notifications, you aren’t left with silence. Instead, there are the sounds of birds in the morning, of rickshaws honking meters away, plates clanking.

One of the most constant parts of the structure of this trip is the waiting. As members of this Dialogue, we take long winding bus rides and sit before meals and learn things about each other. Learning, more broadly speaking, takes place through many avenues: lectures, site visits, climate models and journal articles. However, I learn as much through these things as I do through my encounters with other people.

IMG_6906

My roommate Lila in the Delhi airport

IMG_6903

Climate change chocolate

A member of the Dialogue, Kasha, did her capstone on solar energy and informed me about the differences between commercial and residential solar panels. My roommate, Lila, is teaching me how to play the ukulele.

In another experience, after giving a panel at the University of Burdwan, I received some friend requests from people in audience, students studying economics like me. Over Facebook messenger, we chatted about the caste system and Donald Trump.

Sometimes, people just introduce themselves. In the airport bathroom in Guwahati, a girl with a headband and sweet smile asked me where I was from. “US.” I replied. “What state are you from?” She responded she was from Kolkata, West Bengal. In response, I mumbled something about Kati Rolls.

A few days later, after a five-hour drive into the mountain in a vegetarian restaurant

IMG_6842

Large country, small world

parking lot, I heard a knock on my car window. It was the same girl I had met in the airport!

This third time around, I feel so much more open to meeting new people. Now, I ask questions about what states and cities other people are from with the same aura of recognition that they give me.

It doesn’t hurt, either, that our TA, Udit, acts as a translator wherever we go.

Last night, Udit took me, Rose and Tavish to his aunt’s house for dinner in Delhi. Immediately, in the stairwell of the apartment, Udit’s mom and aunt each gave me a long hug, like I was a part of their family too. While reflecting on this moment, I can’t help but feel suspended. Grateful.

A few days ago, I felt inspired enough about a person I met here to write a poem, my first one in a couple years.

IMG_6770

But first: sunset in Shillong

 

Amit told me the

Bare bones of his life story

Between the traffic

 

Although my sister

Makes fun of my ten and two

I close my eyes and

 

Remember that it’s

Possible to drive through

The south of Mumbai

 

When the lessons take

Place at the age of thirteen.

Dusty rural roads.

 

He said: “I’ve always

Wanted to be an artist,

To paint a canvas

 

So ebullient it

Would make the Louvre explode:

Self-combustion from

 

Pure beauty. Amit

Likes beautiful things which

Makes sense: white walls, huge

 

Bowls of golden sweets,

Grassy parks just before the

Sun is about to

 

Set. That afternoon

I wore an unraveling shawl,

Wavy lines of black

 

Thread left a trail of

Reality. Of cheapness.

In my head, I change

 

Opulence for

Artistry, even when I

Love the things that break

 

Quickly. Between his

Forty seventh and forty

eighth patients of the

 

Day, Amit makes molds

Of broken teeth, sculpting more

Magnificently,

 

With more precision

Than Michelangelo could.

He folds his dreams of

 

Immortality

In a museum somewhere

Into smiles, and

 

An application

To American dentistry

School. Hoping. Waiting.

Posted in 2016 | Tagged , , , , , , , , , | 5 Comments

Gut Feelings

IMG_6710

There was something I couldn’t put my finger on about the hotel we stayed at on Mandarmani beach. Something felt off. Initially, I had a few vague reasons that explained my discomfort.

  1. Immediately, upon opening the gates of the hotel, there is a row of enormous eight-foot statues of bronze horses. They do not resemble any type of animal I saw on the way. To get to the hotel, we drove by villages with chickens, cows and goats. As we got closer there were lobster ponds. But chariots of horses stampeding by the beach? Not a thing, as far as I observed.*
  2. In the center of the property, there was a broken mini children’s roller coaster. Next to it was a foggy glass box with a slightly terrifying life-size sculpture of a clown inside.
  3. One of the people on this trip, Sofia, put it well. “This was probably the hippest place to be in 1992, but nothing has been changed or maintained since then.”

On Saturday, between the insane “morning” hours of 4:30-6:30, I got my answers.

My roommate Lila and I, along with about a dozen others, resolved to catch the sunrise at 4:30 am. We climbed over a padlocked gate and sat on the beach, staring and waiting. For a while, it seemed as if we came during a bad day – the sky potentially too cloudy to catch a glimpse of the rising sun. When we nearly gave up, we stood in the sand and felt the clay beneath our feet. Then, we saw it: a space of emptiness between the clouds. Very briefly, we saw the sun rise until it left a pink after image.

Beautiful.

By that time, Professor Ganguly and his friend Suman were also on the beach. They invited us to ride on these flatbed motorbike vehicles, which we used to travel a few kilometers down the coast to see the red crabs. At one point, as recently as 1990, the beach was completely red, covered with millions of crabs.

IMG_6708

Coconuts being sold on the beach.

Since the development of hotel properties on this coast, the crab population has become endangered. It took about 10 minutes of riding own the coast to see what is left of the red crabs. Like magic, if a person steps onto the sand near the crabs, they disappear into their holes. Poof. They can sense the vibrations. The villagers have been eating these red crabs for years, but the development of hotels on the coastline has significantly affected both the people and crabs who call the Mandarmani area in West Bengal home.

Lucky for me, I sat next to Suman on the ride there and back and he offered some more substantial explanations for my uneasy feeling about the hotel.

First of all, the hotel owner is currently in jail for money laundering. Moreover, the Hindu temple sitting on the coastline is something the original owner invented for tourists. Here’s the biggest kicker: in a few years, all of the properties near the coastline will be demolished because their existence violates environmental regulations.

Suman and I chatted about how bringing hotels to this coast has fundamentally changed the villagers’ way of life. In the past, they used to use agriculture for subsistence, but now, they’re mostly employed as hotel labor, farming less and less.

Watching the 6 am beach, we passed by villagers and tourists alike. Some roamed the shorelines taking pictures while others cast out rope nets for fishing.

When we returned, we witnessed a pack of cows on the beach. It was like I was in a peaceful dream, one that didn’t involve any scary clowns or extremely large horses. I saw a calf drink its mother’s milk. A larger cow licked a cracker right off the palm of my hand.

It was a morning I cannot forget. When I thought about the red crabs disappearing, both into their holes in the moment and also forever, I felt an unprecedented urge to tear up. Normally, I don’t always feel emotional about climate change. But there I was, standing not inside of a dream but in the real world and the effects of the anthropogenic era were right in front of me.

 

*Note of accuracy here, upon further research I learned that horses actually have significant symbolism in Hindu mythology and the first horse is said to have ascended out of the ocean. So not totally out of place.

 

Posted in 2016 | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Why Swimming Pools Are a Human Right

IMG_6667

Holiness everywhere: A Hindu temple just outside of South Mumbai

The Ganges River is seeped in holiness, tradition and pollution. Each year, millions of Hindu pilgrims travel to its riverbanks to bathe in its holy water and cremate their dead. I have a memory from last summer of floating in a rowboat along the river in Varanasi, watching the Ganga Aarti ceremony with one eye and burning funeral pyres with the other. You can view photos of the Ganges or read about its rituals, but being there is something else entirely because you feel it. This is a sacred place.

However, the Ganges is devastated by the effects of man-made pollution and climate change.

It is no surprise that Prime Minister Modi is leading a national effort to clean up the river. India, as a nation of 827 million Hindus, cares deeply about this river’s longevity.

Despite the political challenges that will invariably occur in the process of the Ganges river transformation, the national will for it to be repaired is there.

Mumbai’s Mithi River, however, is a bit of a different story. On Tuesday, we visited an office of the Observer Research Foundation (ORF) in Mumbai to learn about the organization’s work to clean up the Mithi River.

The Mithi River runs through the center of Mumbai, beginning from the Powai Lake and

IMG_6687

My new friend Nimish took us to a park on the Arabian Sea

ending in the Arabian Sea. A good portion of Mumbai natives did not even know the Mithi existed until it lead to the 2005 floods, which took over 1,000 lives. This river, although not one of religious significance, is still filled with so much life that its cleanup is also of vital importance.

Mangroves grow on the banks of the river and it used to be an important source of stormwater drainage. The river runs alongside the slums of Mumbai, like Dharavi, and is now used as a sewer and a trash can.

Sitting in the presentation room, next to future economists, engineers and scientists, I noticed that all of my peers were engaged. The problems surrounding the Mithi River showcase how climate change requires all types of expertise to solve. The Mithi River cleanup needs diversity in expertise: from urban planning to political corruption to ecosystems.

Gautam, our presenter at ORF, ended the presentation with a photo of children swimming in the murky water of the Mithi. Smiling and laughing. Just before, he showed us a photo of brown and black waters converging, brown from sewage, black from petroleum.

IMG_6662

Professor Ganguly. Fun fact: while taking this photo, I broke a glass.

“Mumbai only has three public swimming pools and that in itself is a crime,” he told us. “In this weather, everyone should have access to a swimming pool.”

Everyone deserves access to a swimming pool.

I listened and internalized. Although the thought had never before occurred to me, I realized he was right.

Environmentalism keeps proving to me that global warming is as much about human nature as it is about ecosystems.

On this trip, I have jumped at the chance to find air conditioning and familiar looking toilets and bottles of reliable drinking water. These are the realities of extreme heat and poor sanitation and they seem like obvious inequities.

When I grew up in Southern Arizona, May was a brutal month but I had goggles to save me. I spent a lot of my summers underwater, watching the feet of other swimmers as I only stuck my head above for breaths of air.

There is a list of human rights I think everyone should have. It includes electricity, the right to vote and a good education.

To that list, I add one more: a swimming pool in the summer.

 

Posted in 2016 | Tagged , , , , , , , , , | 1 Comment

People are Flowers and Master’s Degrees are Stars

IMG_6621.jpg

Professor Milind Sohoni of CTARA at IIT-Bombay

Two summers ago, while sitting in a hot, unair-conditioned room in IIT-Bombay I finally got it . There, I learned about the CTARA institute, an advanced degree program for developing rural alternative technologies. I captured a lesson that I carry with me everywhere: caring about climate means caring about people.

To give some context, IIT-Bombay is one of the most competitive colleges in the world. Hundreds of thousands of students take an exam for a handful of spots every year. Once these students are admitted, they could be set for life, using engineering degrees to earn an ample living. Instead, I learned from brilliant people who use their genius to create a better planet and better lives for the rural poor.

As a whole, the experience of being in India in May cements how interlinked human rights and climate issues are. Extreme weather and global warming here is impossible to ignore. It’s the sweat on our skin. It’s the solemn realization that a 12-year-old girl died from the heat waves last month while fetching water.

This morning, Professor Ganguly told us on the bus that CTARA sounds like the Sanskrit word for star. In a way, CTARA is my north star. If you asked me, “When was the moment you really started to care? When did your perception change?” I will always point to CTARA.

IMG_6635

My notes are all webs of connection

Naturally, the lecture from CTARA’s head, Professor
Milind Sohoni, was one of the parts of this year’s itinerary I most looked forward to. His talk was another testament to the idea that everything is connected.

According to Professor Sohoni, climate risk, inequality and a monolithic global culture are all increasing together. His vision of CTARA is a new path forward, one that embraces diverse roles for women, uses science and social science and economics to solve problems and asks engineers work at the micro-level of the community.

Professor Sohoni inspired me for two reasons. First, he was unabashedly optimistic that his vision could happen. Second, he started off his lecture with a story of self. I know a bit about the master’s degree program at CTARA but I also know the words of a lullaby from his childhood.

“What if I hide in the caretaker’s garden? How will you find me?”

“I will become another flower and Baba will string us together in a garland.”

IMG_6636

The flower garland I received immediately after stepping out of the airport in Mumbai

After the talk, we walked to the labs and workshops CTARA runs where they develop the actual technology. On the way, I stopped to speak with a graduate student, Parth, who had been there for a year and a half. His whole demeanor was striking, a permanent smile of contentedness resting behind every word.

One experience typical of CTARA students is a 9-week stay in a rural village, where students implement engineering solutions for the community. Parth was sent to a Marathi village, even though he doesn’t speak the language. He wasn’t phased by not knowing how to speak Marathi and instead emphasized how appreciative the people in the village were.

Before coming to CTARA, Parth decided not to work for a company that sold tractors. He moved out of the agriculture sector and the master’s program changed his life. “A year and a half ago my personality was completely different,” he told me. “I’m not worried about the future. I have everything I need: food and a roof.” Post-graduation, Parth will work for the Ministry of Rural Development.

IMG_6629

Parth and I take a selfie

Hearing Parth talk about being happy with what you have challenged me. I related to the idea of the silliness in worrying about personal success when the real things we need belong to us already. However, he also said, “Every Indian can’t have a car. Every Indian can’t have air conditioning. There just aren’t enough resources. We have to be satisfied with what is.”

I was frustrated. Why? And then I realized he wasn’t necessarily wrong, either. I do not know whether or not to understand the world as it is or to always be fueled by a sense of discontent.

Questions surrounding climate change always involve questions without easy answers, which is why I think that some of the people I admire most work on this issue. They’re the kinds of people that are not afraid of being stumped sometimes.

I left IIT’s campus today inspired and motivated as ever, but this time, with a sincere lack of resolution. The problems feel bigger and bigger and bigger the more I know.

 

Posted in 2016 | Tagged , , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Good Luck Charms

Lucky Charms cereal bowl

Twenty four hours before flight 0421 leaves Boston for Mumbai, I raced around my house searching for a good luck charm. My bedroom floor, already a tornado of sunscreen bottles and flowy pants, became even more hazardous as I searched through its very last uncharted territories. I can’t help myself. For better or worse, I am a superstitious person. During all of my co-op interviews, I wore the same dress because I was afraid I would stop getting job offers if I decided on a different outfit. In my journal, I write with the same blue pen. Nicknacks and trinkets give me comfort and continuity.

This is my third time back in India, and you know what they say about three.

Eventually, I settled on the item that would bring me goodwill for this trip: the Star of David necklace my grandma bought for me. Necklaces, in particular, have meaning. For a while now, I have been flirting with the idea of wearing a Star of David necklace every day. What would openly wearing my Jewishness feel like? How would it change my life, if at all? The more I considered it, the idea of luck and this next stage of my life, the more right the choice of necklace shape felt. Wearing the Star of David was something I needed to do.

On last year’s trip, I wore one of my hamsas. To explain: the hamsa is shaped like an open palm and is popular across the Middle East among both Arabs and Jews. It’s supposed to protect against the evil eye and bring power and strength to its wearer. I never knew much about why I wore a hand around my neck; I just did.

However, on the day we visited Mother Teresa’s Tomb, two mystical things happened: the stone in the middle of my necklace fell out. That felt significant. I’d never been in a place quite like Mother Teresa’s Tomb, subdued, otherworldly, hushed. I couldn’t take pictures. In that space, my ward of protection broke down, just slightly. Then, just after we left the tomb and my stone disappeared, our bus driver got into an accident with another bus. In order to stop the other bus driver from leaving and getting away with the accident, our driver laid down on the street in front of the driver, offering the threat of being ran over to prevent the other man’s getaway. Life hung in the balance outside my window. I clasped my deformed necklace. I didn’t know what to think.

At home, in 2016, I put on the gold Star of David necklace. If my religion is providing meaning to small objects, hers is worrying. She was so proud that I’d be wearing my grandmothers necklace until…until..”What about anti-Semitism?” she asked. The question stood between us. I didn’t want to take the necklace off. I still don’t know: is there anti-Semitism in India? The complex thoughts I have about anti-Semitism in the United States did not prepare for me her question or my answer. I took the necklace off.

Instead, I put on another piece of my grandma’s, a mezuzah, which is deeply religious but not as immediately identifiable. Mezuzahs, traditionally, have a scroll of prayer inside of them that declare faith to G-d. Jews are commanded to put mezuzahs on the entrances of their homes.

Here is a list of the things I am not:

  • A Doorpost
  • A Flag
  • A Representation
  • A Master at iPhone Photography

I plan on updating this blog more later with information on the independent research supporting my travel to India (thank you, Northeastern) and our itinerary, but for now, one last thought:

Most times, I don’t know what I believe. If there’s one thing I do believe, though, it’s that I’m bringing something with me to India tomorrow — meaning, a story, a heritage, lots of questions. Five weeks from now, when I fly from Delhi to Boston to Tucson I will carry something, or lots of things, back.

 

 

 

 

 

Posted in 2016, Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Buildings and Books

Marita selfie-ing by the Taj

Marita selfie-ing by the Taj

At 5:30 am today, the air was cool and damp. The sky was cloudy. We didn’t see the sunrise. Rather, the sky gradually lightened, becoming less eerie and more normal by the minute. The Taj before tourists arrive is magnificent; there’s no other way to put it.

It can be my new fun fact, Kara said. I’ve been to the Taj Mahal twice.

This second time, like a lot of the other second times, I was more in tune. I heard the stories our tour guide, Punam, told us more clearly. I understood the background better. The words were sharper.

IMG_4508

One story stood out, though, at the Agra Fort, just a short drive from the Taj Mahal.

The Agra Fort was built by Shah Jahan’s grandfather, Emperor Akbar. Shah Jahan died in the Agra Fort, imprisoned there by his own son. Although the Agra Fort, sometimes referred to as the Red Fort, is less iconic than the Taj, it remains a striking monument in its own right.

IMG_4552Although Emperor Akbar was a natural at building and imparted some of his architectural genius to his grandson, he was unable to read and write. Instead, he learned the lessons of warfare. Akbar’s father, Hauman, died falling down the steps of the library. Although Hauman’s death probably has more to do with an opium affliction rather than a reading one and Akbar’s illiteracy was probably more about empire-building than suspicion, I like to pretend that Akbar purposely didn’t learn to read. Maybe he was trying to avoid the grim fate of his father.

Unlike Emperor Akbar, the members of this dialogue can’t get enough of reading. The

Shah Jahan's prison view of his mausoleum.

Shah Jahan’s prison view of his mausoleum.

space in our brains we could have used for war-mongering is left open for books.

Personally, I completed five books on this trip. My personal voraciousness was not unmatched. Books accompanied us everywhere, from our bus rides to our hotel rooms. We traded some dog-eared pages for others, knowing what was old to us was new to someone else. When we finished one lent copy, we shared something different than just being in the same place.

It’s an element of this experience that I’ll miss: our collective library. By us and for us.

So, if you wanted to live like the Northeastern 2015 Climate Dialoguer-s, here’s a list of 5 books someone was reading sometime:

This Changes Everything – Naomi Klein

Naomi Klein came to campus in April. Many of the members of the Dialogue were able to see her speak. Pedro read the entire 430 pages during spring break. I gave my finished copy to Kara. Joanna brought hers along as well. Whether or not you agree with Ms. Klein’s politics (I do, I think), there’s a powerful message here: climate change touches everything we do, everything we are. We have to address it.

A Tree Grows in Brooklyn – Betty Smith

Alina brought this book, a gift from her mom. At least two other people here have finished it. When Alina finished “A Tree Grows in Brooklyn,” she cried. The tears moved everyone around her.

The Argumentative Indian – Amartya Sen

Anything Amartya Sen writes is something I’m usually on board with. Professor Ganguly bought his copy in the Delhi airport.

I Am Malala – Malala Yousafazi

Rache was reading “I Am Malala” on the train to Delhi. Kiera told me, over lunch, “everyone should read this book.” Although we’re not in Pakistan, I think after being here, we can all understand the challenges Malala faces a little better.

Siddhartha – Herman Hesse

Life-changing book on spirituality. We were able to see the Great Stupa and attend Hindu rituals, but these 115 pages give Eastern religions even more context. I gave my copy to Nick Ireland. This book impacted me in a way not many can.

Here’s a list of others, too:

White Teeth

The Second Sex

Flood of Fire

Half A Yellow Sun

Angels and Demons

Born to Run

Love in the Time of Cholera

Norwegian Wood

1984

Middlesex

Slaughterhouse Five

The Red Sari

The Kite Runner

Aloft

Posted in 2015 | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment